Sunday, April 22, 2012

Veldman_Reflection

Steve Veldman—Understanding the Cause of the Seasons-Lesson Plan Reflection
  • A brief description of your lesson plan, noting any changes you made since your original draft in Module 5.
      My lesson plan revolved around changing misconceptions about the cause of the seasons.  My students started by conducting research online to discover the average temperatures of certain locations on earth at various times of the year.  They then compared that data with the proximity of the earth to the sun during those times.  They then drew conclusions about the effect that proximity to the sun has on the weather and seasons.  Once their prior misconception was erased, they then were asked to search online for the correct explanation about the seasons.  Once that research was done, they were required to create a poster that could be used as a stand alone instructional piece on the reason for the seasons.
  • A brief narrative of your implementation of the lesson. Who were the students and how did everything go?
      The implementation of the lesson went very much as planned in the original lesson.  My class is composed of a diverse group of 27 fifth grade students.  Represented in the group are very high achieving students, very low achieving students, a large group in the middle.  I have both general education and special education students in the classroom.  Due to our work throughout the year, my students all have adequate technological skills, and were all able to complete the lesson.
  • What was learned? What were the learning goals of this instructional experience? What were the underlying assumptions (explicit and implicit) about the nature of knowledge?
            The students in my fifth grade class have always struggled with learning about the cause of the seasons.  Additionally, the video  “Private Universe” from the beginning of this class sparked my interest in devising a lesson that addresses the issue.  This lesson was       designed to meet the Michigan Grade Level Content Expectations: 
            E.ES.M.6 Seasons- Seasons result from annual variations in
            the intensity of sunlight and length of day due to the tilt of
            the axis of the Earth relative to the plane of its yearly
            orbit around the sun.
            E.ES.05.61 Demonstrate and explain seasons using a model. *
            E.ES.05.62 Explain how the revolution of the Earth around the
            sun defines a year.
      Going into the lesson, I had many previous assumptions about where my students’ knowledge levels would be that were based on my past experiences teaching this content.  I knew that personal experiences would give the students self-created explanations that were usually contradictory to the actual scientific explanation.  Through this course, I learned how to discover those misconceptions within my students, and work towards fixing them.     
  • What are the affordances for how knowledge/information is being represented? What are the constraints?
      In this lesson, the students will be discovering knowledge on their own.  In order to do so, they will be conducting online research.  The best thing about interacting with knowledge this way is that it makes the content much more meaningful.  Instead of have information forced at them, the students will be discovering it on their own, which I have found to be much more effective.
  • How does learning take place? What elements of constructivism did you observe? What elements of behaviorism did you observe? Were any other learning theories present?
      In this lesson, the learning takes place as students make discoveries on their own.  They looked up data, and then drew conclusions based on the data.  The act of discovery that existed in the lesson led to very high levels of student engagement, and a very impressive final product for nearly all students. 
      The lesson was designed with constructivist theories in mind.  I knew that students in the past had developed certain schemas that explained how the earth had seasons.  Unfortunately, many of those schemas were wrong, and they had a very difficult time accommodating the new information with their pre-existing thoughts.  In this new lesson, I wanted the students to work to adjust their own schemas.  I knew that through the data gathering and the subsequent drawing of conclusions, they would be in a state of mental disequilibrium, which they then would be eager to fix by looking for an alternate explanation.
      In keeping with the behaviorist theory of learning, I did have my students create a product at the end of their learning.  It is impossible to tell what students are thinking unless they physically produce something that shows insight into their thought processes.  By having my students create a poster, I could tell which students truly understood the concepts, and which students need a little more time to work through things.
  • Was your lesson intended to supplement or supplant existing curriculum? Or, was it intended to enhance the learning of something already central to the curriculum or some new set of understandings or competencies?
      This lesson was designed as a supplement to a very extensive unit on our solar system and the interactions of the objects contained within.  As previously mentioned students in my classroom historically have struggled greatly with the concept.  Therefore, I am always looking for new ideas and concepts that will help students understand about the earth’s interactions with the sun in a better way.
  • How are important differences among learners taken into account?
      Differences amongst learners are always a great concern of mine when teaching a lesson.  As we discussed earlier in this class individuals learn in many different ways.  As an educator, it is my responsibility to ensure that all of my lessons are designed in a way that is accessible to all learning styles.  Since this lesson was created as a very student centric activity, it naturally adjusts to fit the needs of all students.  By allowing my students the freedom to accomplish the tasks in anyway they felt comfortable, they naturally fit the lesson to their own learning style.
  • What do teachers and learners need to know in order for your lesson to be a success? What demands are placed on teachers and other "users"? What knowledge is assumed?
      In order for my lesson to be successful students need to have a basic understanding of how to conduct basic online research skills.  To complete the lesson they will need to look up information online and record the data.  Following that, they will need to be able to analyze the data and draw conclusions.  In this lesson, the teacher serves more as a facilitator of learning than a source of information.  Their primary job during the lesson will be to guide students through any troubles they might encounter and troubleshoot potential pitfalls.  Going into the lesson, I assume that my students will have the skills necessary to complete the research portion of the assignment and correctly interpret the data to subsequently draw the appropriate conclusions.
  • How did you assess what students were doing and what they were learning from this activity? How did you hold them accountable for the work they did?
      To assess my students I had them create a mini-poster.  The requirement that they were given was that the poster should be designed as a stand alone instructional piece.  They needed to include all the information and diagrams necessary to ensure that someone looking at the poster could learn about the cause for earth’s seasons.  Following the poster’s completion, the students placed them in the hallway outside of our classroom, where all students in the building could benefit from the information.

Question Set Two
  • What role does technology play in your lesson? What advantages or disadvantages does the technology hold for this role? What unique contribution does the technology make in facilitating learning?
      Technology played a major role in my lesson.  Without technology, the lesson, as it was designed, would be impossible to complete.  The students need to conduct online research to discover information about the impact of proximity to the sun on temperature.  By using technology, students had the opportunity to personally discover information instead of passively accepting information given to them.  Through technology this lesson shifts from a teacher centered passing on of information to a student centered active search for knowledge.
  • What did you expect your students to make of their use of technology in your lesson? How did they react when using the technologies? What questions did students have, and how did you respond to them?
      I expected students to use technology to discover new knowledge.  The students in my class had previous experience with online research, and in fact we spent several weeks in the beginning of the school year discussing the best ways to search out information.  Therefore, the research aspect of the lesson went quite well.  The only trouble in the technological portion of the lesson was that a few students were getting conflicting information from websites.  However, after discussing the results as a class we were able to collaboratively reach an agreement on the correct numerical information.
      Most of the student questions came from the section of the lesson where the students had to draw conclusions based on the data.  Since the data they found went against many of their prior misconceptions, my students were very reluctant to accept the new information.  They asked many questions about whether the data was correct or whether there existed other reasons to explain what they were seeing.
  • How would you describe how students were making sense of the content with the technology?
      Through the use of technology my students were successfully able to negotiate through a very difficult concept.  I planned the lesson knowing that students would have to face their misconceptions about the cause of seasons, and I hoped that through technological discovery they would come to a new understanding.  After working through the lesson with my class, I found that exact result.  My students were put in a state of mental disequilibrium, and through the use of technology, they were able to rethink their ideas, and assimilate new correct information to take the place of the misconceptions.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Steve's Calendar