Tuesday, July 24, 2012

Literature Review


            The population of migrant students in the United States continues to grow, with recent estimates placing the number at nearly 1,000,000 students nationwide.  With this increase, and the accountability that school districts face with standards based testing, educators across the country are looking for more effective ways to reach this underserved population.  While this population faces many of the same challenges as other socio-economically disadvantaged populations, it also has a unique challenge; the fact that the students change schools multiple times during the course of their education.  While other challenging student popluations have the opportunity to receive support and intervention through an educational plan set up by their home district, the migrant student population often does not receive the benefits of those programs.  Due to the transitory nature of their education, many school districts place these students in their periphery and neglect to meet their needs.
            This research study looks into the effect that this transitory schooling has on the perceptions of the students.  How does the fact that their status as temporary students relegates them to the background of schools’ efforts, affect their perception of school?  Overall, very little has been said scholarly on this topic.  Despite the fact that this is a growing population, no definative research has been done on the effects that continual transitions have on the migrant student population.  In fact, within the world of migrant education, very little substantive work has been recently done about any topic.  The majority of published work involving the area of migrant education was conducted over a decade ago.  While age alone does not make a study irrelevent, a study of a community’s sense of culture that does not reflect the modern shift in communication and online communities must be viewed as lacking a central component of understanding how today’s social perceptions are developed.  Yet, those aging sources will still be reviewed as they do provide an account of former migrant educational practices.  In contrast, the study of the effects of classroom culture has been thoroughly researched, providing many substantive studies that review the importance of that area. 
            For this literature review, focus will be made on the two main areas encapsulated within this research study, the education of the migrant population and the effects of school culutre on a student’s academic perception.  Unfortunatley, no study has yet been conducted that attempts to connect the two areas, as this research study hopes to accomplish, but looking at each area separately will still provide insight into how each area affects the educational perceptions of transitory students.
            The first area of literature related to this research study is the area of migrant education.  Alvarez McHatton, Zalaquett, and Cranson-Gringas (2006) present statistics and general data in an effort to charactarize the migrant student.  Along with Kindler (1995), they paint a picture of the migrant student as a student who fits certain criteria.  First, the student, and their family, move residences, often across state lines, in search of employment.  Of particular note to this study are those students whose families move in search of agricultural employment.  Second, the student comes from a family that often speaks a language other than English.  Kindler (1995) noted that in nearly 90% of migrant students’ homes a language other than English is the primary language. Third, due to the continual movement, they often underachieve academically.  Alvarez McHatton, Zalaquett, and Cranson-Gringas (2006) found that nearly 50% of migrant students dropout before high school graduation.  DiCerbo (2001) defines the attempts educators have made to succeed in reaching migrant students.  The history of migrant education is discussed, along with a quick overview of the history of the Migrant Education Program (MEP).  Green (2003) also attempts to frame the problem of migrant education, but does so through the view of migrant students as undocumented illegal immigrants.  While this may be the case in rare circumstances, the majority of migrant students are legal citizens of the United States.  Therefore, the Green (2003) study is of little importance to this research report.
            Of primary significance to this study is Children of La Frontera: Binational Efforts To Serve Mexican Migrant and Immigrant Students Flores (1996).  This large compilation of articles and research findings within the field of migrant education gives valuable insights into the unique challenges faced by the migrant student population.  Many articles exist describing the current state of migrant education, from 1996, as well as the history of migrant education. Of special interest to this research study is the section of the book devoted to working with the migrant families.  The articles in this section present that the increased engagement of the migrant families will lead to greater success for the migrant students.  A further connection is presented that increased parental involvemnt would lead to lower levels of migrant dropout.  Additionally, the book presents successful interventions for migrant students such as increased used of materials that relate to the Hispanic culture, improved English Language Learner services, and increased cooperation between the various districts from which migrant students transition.
            The above mentioned studies provide a look into the best research in the field of migrant education.  However, as previously mentioned, there exists very little quality research about this field.  Therefore, this research study takes on an added importance.
            The second area of literature related to this research study is the area of school culture and the effect that it has on a student’s academic perception.  Samdal, Nutbeam, Wold, and Kannas (1998)  reviewed the effects that a student’s perceptions had on their overall satisfaction with their school experience.  The study used perception surveys to find that students needed a quality relationship with their teacher, a sense of a larger learning community, and a sense of self-determination within their education.  This feeling of self determination was the area of primary importance in the Origins and Pawns study done by Ryan and Grolnick (1986).  The study looked at self-determination in the classroom as the single most important factor in a student’s satisfaction with their education.  Due to their transitory nature, and the continual unease of attending new schools with new people, it can be argued that migrant student have a lower sense of self-determination than their age level peers.
            In addtion to Ryan and Grolnick’s (1986) and Samdal, Nutbeam, Wold, and Kannas’ (1998) studies on self-determination’s affect on perceptions, other quality studies have also looked into the effects that goal setting has on students’ perceptions of classroom culture.  Ames and Archer (1988) show that meaningful goal setting by students provides them with incentives that lead to higher academic performance and greater personal satisfication with their education.  Additionally, Skinner and Belmont (1993) review the steps that teachers and students can take, using goal setting as one possible route to success, to increase student engagement, satisfaction with their learning, and overall academic performance.
            After reviewing the existing literature, it is clear that a semblance of consensus exists amongst the various studies.  All studies show that when a student feels a sense of ownership in their learning, their desire to succeed and grow academically increases.   Nutbeam, Wold, and Kannas (1998) took the idea one step farther when they discussed the benefits of creating a classwide system that fosters a culture of personal ownership and learning for all students.
            In this research study the two areas of study will be linked, comparing how the unique challenges presented in the migrant population have affected those students’ perceptions of school.  Using the work of Alvarez McHatton, Zalaquett, and Cranson-Gringas (2006) regarding migrant education, it is clear that their are successful interventions that can be made to help the migrant population.  Additionally, the work of Samdal, Nutbeam, Wold, and Kannas (1998)  shows that students who feel more successful in school, and have a higher sense of self-determination, view their academic expeience in a more positive manner.  The challenge that exists is creating a situation where those two areas coincide to create an enjoyable and successful academic experience for students with transitory schooling patterns.  As DiCerbo (2001)  suggested, the migrant student population faces a difficult situation, but by improving those students’ perception of their educational experience, strides can be made to improve their academic achievement.
           















References
Ames, Carole, Archer, Jennifer. (1988) Achievement Goals in the Classroom: Students' Learning
Strategies and Motivation Processes.  Journal of Educational Psychology, Vol. 80, No. 3. Retrieved from: http://leg.ufpr.br/lib/exe/fetch.php/projetos:educacao:ames_c._1988.pdf
Alvarez McHatton, Patricia, Zalaquett, Carlos, Cranson-Gringas, Ann. (2006)
Achieving Success: Perceptions of Students from Migrant Farmwork  Families.
American Secondary Education, Spring 2006. Retrieved from: http://www.ncfh.org/pdfs/6457.pdf
DiCerbo, Patricia Anne.(2001) Why Migrant Education Matters. National Clearinghouse for
 Bilingual Education, No. 8. February 2001. Retrieved from:
Flores, Judith LeBlanc. (1996)  Children of La Frontera: Binational Efforts To Serve Mexican
Migrant and Immigrant Students.
Kindler, A.  (1995)  Education of Migrant Children in the United States. Directions in Language
And Education .  National Clearinghouse of Bilingual Education, Vol. 1, No. 8, Fall 1995. Retrieved from: http://www.ncela.gwu.edu/files/rcd/BE020672/Educating_Migrant_Students___.pdf

Ryan, Richard M., Grolnick, Wendy S. (1986)  Origins and Pawns in the Classroom: Self-Report
and  Projective Assessments of Individual Differences in Children's Perceptions.  Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Vol. SO, No. 3. Retrieved from: http://ww.selfdeterminationtheory.org/SDT/documents/1986_RyanGrolnick_JPSP.pdf
Samdal, O, Nutbeam, D, Wold, B, Kannas, L.  (1998) Achieving health and educational goals
through schools—a study of the importance of the school climate and the students' satisfaction with school.  Health Education Research--Theory & Practice Vol.13 no.3.
Skinner, Ellen A., Belmont, Michael J. (1993) Motivation in the Classroom: Reciprocal Effects
of Teacher Behavior and Student Engagement Across the School Year.  Journal of Educational Psychology, Vol. 85, No. 4. Retrieved from: http://www.selfdeterminationtheory.org/SDT/documents/1993_SkinnerBelmont_JEP.pdf
Green, Paul E. (2003)  The Undocumented: Educating the Children of Migrant Workers in

Steve's Calendar