Saturday, March 10, 2012

Wicked Problem Project Final Product



Screencast Transcript

            Hello and welcome to my Wicked Problem Final Product Screencast.  My name is Steve Veldman, and during this presentation I will discuss the Wicked Problem of Practice I attempted to solve, how I attempted to solve it, the way in which my solution fit with the TPACK model, and what my overall results were during this process.
            First, let’s discuss the Wicked Problem of Practice I hoped to address.  Throughout my years of teaching, I have always struggled with ways to make writing an engaging and enriching process.  Through trial and error I have develop a writing creation process that students enjoy and that produces adequate results.  However, within that process one piece has never been up to par, the area of editing and revising.  Students hate editing and revising.  Its tedious nature leaves my students looking for anything else to do besides edit and revise.  Despite my many attempts to try group work or vary their routines, my students have never found the process intellectually stimulating.  Additionally, the lack of motivation left their revisions and edits falling incredibly short of what I expected them to produce.  Therefore, I felt it was the perfect candidate to attempt to address with technology.  I spent quite a bit of time searching the internet to determine my best course of action.  I found a variety of resources, which you can see here, that helped me develop my plan.
            So, here is what I planned for my students to do.  To start off, my students would type up previously handwritten stories.  Once their stories were finished typed products, they would begin their editing and revision process.  First, they would copy their stories and paste them into the vocalization program at vozme.com.  This program takes written text and creates an mP3 file that students can listen to.  The site has an embedded player that allows the user to play, pause, and move throughout the audio file.  The students would then be required to listen to their story as vozme read it aloud, and make corrections as needed.  After completing that task the students would share their stories with their classmates using edmodo.com.  The students in my class have been using edmodo for quite some time, so the sharing process would be quite easy for them.  Once the stories were shared with their classmates, the students would then be paired up and be required to peer revise their classmate’s writing.  To aide in the revising process, the students would use the comments feature in Microsoft Word.  When they had completed their comments, they would send the story back to its owner who would make the necessary corrections.  In all, the project was planned to last approximately twelve 30-minute computer lab sessions.
            My plan was based on designing an activity that would fit perfectly in the middle of the TPACK framework.  To highlight this fit, I am going to discuss three TPACK interactions within my project.  The first is an interaction between Content and Technology.  As do all teachers, I realize that the daunting task of addressing all of the required curriculum means that no time can be wasted.  Therefore, everything I do, this project included, must fit with the Michigan Grade Level Content Expectations.  This project addressed two GLCEs:  First  W.PR.05.05  which states that the students should be able to proofread and edit writing using grade-level checklists and other appropriate resources both individually and in groups, and second W.PR.05.04  which states that the students should be able to revise drafts based on constructive and specific oral and written responses to writing by identifying sections of the piece to improve organization and flow of ideas  The first GLCE fit perfectly with the technology provided by vozme.com.  The second GLCE on the other hand, fit well with Microsoft Word.  The GLCE expects students to comment critically on other students’ work, and work to improve their writing.  I feel that using Microsoft Word comments greatly added in my students’ ability to reach that objective.  On a quick side note, at the bottom of the three TPACK Interactions slides, you will see a portion of the stories that the students were able to create through this process.  I have not altered these stories in any way, other than place them in a screenshot so you can see pieces of their work.  In addition to the content and technology interactions, I want to highlight two instances where Technology and Pedagogy interact.
            The first technology and pedagogy interaction I will discuss is how the use of vozMe.com fits with what I hope to accomplish pedagogically.  I am a firm believer in a constructivist model of education.  I feel, and research agrees with me, that in order to truly gain new knowledge a process of discovery must exist within each learner.  When students are given an opportunity to discern knowledge on their own, it becomes much more meaningful.  By using vozMe.com and listening to their stories, my students would be able to find their own errors.  They would be able to realize common mistakes they make, and adjust their future writings accordingly.
            The second interaction with technology and pedagogy involves the Microsoft Word comments.  We live in a very socially driven world, and the recent explosion of technological advances has only served to heighten that fact.  Online interactions have allowed people to learn from each other in a myriad of ways.  This trend meshes perfectly with the social constructivist model of learner pioneered by Vygotsky.  My experiences in teaching have led me to complete agree with his ideas that people take their cues in learning from their interactions with those around them.  Therefore, I designed my project to take advantage of this innate learning modality.  Through the use of the Microsoft Word comments feature, my students were able to interact and learn from each other.  The process of reviewing their peer’s work, assisted the other students in improving their writing, but also allowed the reviewer a chance to reflect on what qualities they feel exist in a good writing piece, which was something they were able to use when they went back to their own work.
            So, how did my project go?  Overall, I found it to be a great success.  The process was able to dramatically increased student engagement in the process.  My prior attempts at revising and editing without using the technology were always met with groans of agony from my class.  Their actual correcting was done as quickly as possible so that they could move on to a more desirable activity.  As a result, the products they produced were very poor.  That was not the case when they used this process.  The final products were very well done.  The constructivist nature of this project meant this was a much more student driven process, which led to a greater sense of ownership for all students.  Therefore, they all took great pride in what they were creating, and it showed in the end.  The greatest outcome was the exponential increases in student excitement about editing.
            So the real question now is, did I solve a “Wicked Problem of Practice.”  I think the answer is partially.  I feel that I have had great success with this project, but there are a few tweaks that I will have to make in the future to perfect the result.  In the weeks since I have implemented this project I have seen the skills that the students developed in editing, revising, and social collaboration transfer into many other areas of study, which increases my perception of success within my Wicked Project.  The best thing I can say about the project is that it has transferred my students cries from “Do we have to edit our writing this time?” to “When do we get to do that cool editing thing again?’  Which is music to an educator's ears.

1 comment:

  1. Your final product is well organized and polished. Thank you for your hard work and excellent summary.

    Again, I appreciate how you had the GLCE standards help focus your project. Furthermore, situating your project on the foundation of your constructivist philosophy created solid ground for you to build upon.

    If you don't mind, I am going to share this with a few English teachers and student teachers. You have identified a common problem...and I think others can certainly learn from you. Thanks for sharing!

    I love your conclusion...it is a nice way to wrap up. Well done!

    ReplyDelete

Steve's Calendar