Thursday, February 2, 2012

Wicked Project Part A

In recent years, one area of emphasis amongst the curriculum in my district has been writing across all content areas. Therefore, the amount of student writing has increased greatly. While I have generally seen the writing improve, one area has remained a difficulty, editing. Students absolutely hate editing their work. They feel that once they have put forth the effort writing something once, they do not need to go back and revise that same piece. Knowing this I have increasingly moved toward peer editing and revising. Students share work with one another, and allow their classmates to provide the feedback necessary to improve the writings.
I feel the model is necessary, but the process is very tedious and sloppy. Therefore, I am now hoping to turn to technology to help solve the issue that I have always dealt with. For the next piece of student writing, an adventure story following Joseph Campbell’s Hero’s Journey, I am having the students type their rough drafts. I then plan to have the students upload their writings to their edmodo accounts. Through those accounts, they will be able to share their stories with their classmates.
As for how the classmates will interact with the stories, I have not yet decided. I have done some research and have come up with two possibilities. The first is to type in text on their classmates stories using an alternate text color. The benefits of this is that it will be very easy to see and will require action by the original author. However, this method could cause problems within the original text, especially because my students are very unskilled at text editing.
The second option, and the one I will most likely use, is the comments feature. I like the fact that the comments are unobtrusive yet are able to convey the necessary messages. The only concern I have is that the students will have the option to ignore all comments, which some of my less ambitious students might be tempted to do.
In addition to the comments features, I also am planning to use vozme.com to assist the students.  Before sharing their writings with others, the students will copy and paste their typed stories into vozme.  They can then listen to their story being read by vozme, and follow along on a hard copy.  They will be able to pause and review areas that need further work, and will be able to interact with their writing in a new way.
Using technology to edit student writing I hope to infuse some excitement into the process. Editing writing will never become the favorite event of my students, but I hope to make it much more bearable. In order to gage the success of this I plan to give my class a survey (using my newly gained survey expertise) where they will rate their experiences with this process. Previously I have given the students a survey where they on a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 being the most enjoyable experience, they rated our editing process an average of 2.4. Obviously, it was something that needed to be worked on.
My students have already begun to type their stories, and while it is a very slow process, I plan to be done typing and ready for editing by February 10. Throughout that next week, the students will begin their editing through technology. I plan to evaluate the success of this process, and adjust accordingly for future iterations of the editing process.
I am very excited about attempting to tackle this issue. For years now, it has been an unenjoyable chore for both my students and me. I feel that through the use of technology I can ease the process and add some much-needed excitement.

Resources
How to Use Vozme
http://attheteachersdesk.blogspot.com/2010/09/universal-design-tool-vozmecom.html
http://www.teachertube.com/viewVideo.php?title=Vozme___A_New_Way_to_Podcast&video_id=96397

Using Comments Feature in Microsoft Word
http://wordprocessing.about.com/od/wordprocessingsoftware/a/comments.htm
http://www.oucs.ox.ac.uk/ltg/teachingwithtechnology/TG-wordcomments.pdf
http://cai.ucdavis.edu/caihandouts/writingwithmword.html

Student Writing & Editing Through Technology
http://wik.ed.uiuc.edu/index.php/Improving_Student_Writing_Using_Technology
http://www.landmark.edu/institute/assistive_technology/writing_technology.html
http://www.atia.org/files/ATOBV1N1A4.pdf

5 comments:

  1. Steve,
    You are addressing a very real problem in many classrooms. Students at higher levels continue to struggle with this same issue (I see it college now, too). I appreciate the foundation you are laying down and modeling for your students already in 5th grade! Using Edmodo is an excellent idea. I'm excited to hear your success story. :) I think it was a great idea to survey students before implementing your strategy. This will give you good data to speak to when analyzing your results.
    I'm sure you will learn a lot...and you will figure out what needs to be tweaked.
    Good luck!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Writing is one of my students' biggest problem! I find that many of my students are great communicating their ideas, but writing them down creates a much larger problem. Not only that, but writing using a computer takes them much longer and they cannot compose a document using the computer. This is a tough task to tackle, but I think it will be great. Do you have access to any ipads or touch screen that they could practice editing marks? Have you thought about incorporating more internet resources to help them practice editing or proofreading? It might be great to have them do a writing process webquest prior to editing each others work online. They might also enjoy having some sort of wallwisher or program to be able to move themselves through the process and what stage their writing currently is in. I came across this site (but don't actually teach writing) and thought it might be useful. I haven't explored it at all thought http://www.essaypunch.com/
    I'm sure this practice and use of technology will really help your students either love writing or love editing - or both!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great idea Steve! I too have the same problem with my fifth graders and their lack of revising and editing their paper effectively. After reading through their paper once and coming to me two minutes later, they think they are done. This needs to be changed and I think you have a great idea to do so. I can see the problems with your idea as you noted (time consuming to type, students deleting or ignoring comments, etc) however, I believe you can be successful with finding the right tools to build student interest in their writing. It might be fun to practice editing with comments on a very humorous writing piece that you create. Make sure it doesn't make sense, but be very proud of it! This may draw them in to help you become a better writer as they will do with others.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think this is a great idea! Since I am a substitute teacher I have the opportunity to work with students at all grade levels in the elementary school. This is a problem I have seen in all the classes I have taught in! I agree that the best way to have them peer edit is to use the comment section, at least at first. As your students become more familiar with the process and the technology, you may be able to introduce other options! I am not familiar with Edmodo at all, so I look forward to hearing how it works for your class!

    ReplyDelete

Steve's Calendar