For my Wicked Project I am trying to solve the persistent problem that my students have with editing their writing. As I discussed previously in my Wicked Project Part A Blog, I have tried many different ways to increase excitement and student engagement in editing, but have not found any real successes. Therefore, I am trying to tackle this problem through technology. In my Part B Blog I will be reviewing my plans and seeing how they fit with the TPACK framework.
TC- Technology & Content
The first section I will discuss is content and how technology will support it. The reason I place it first is a time matter. With so much content included in the grade level content expectations, time must be squarely focused on the required material. As much as I, and most educators, would like to teach things that we enjoy or find interesting, we have to focus on the essential content. Therefore, every lesson I teach is based on the content expectations for 5th grade.
My editing project is designed to meet the following Michigan Grade Level Content Expectations:
W.PR.05.04 revise drafts based on constructive and specific oral and written responses
to writing by identifying sections of the piece to improve organization and flow of ideas
(e.g., position/evidence organizational pattern, craft such as titles, leads, endings, and
powerful verbs).
W.PR.05.05 proofread and edit writing using grade-level checklists and other
appropriate resources both individually and in groups.
Based on what the expectations require, I feel that my two proposed technologies will each assist in accomplishing one of the objectives. My plan to use vozme.com to allow students to hear their story read to them will greatly assist in the second objective. The students will have a hard copy of their story, and while listening to the story being read, they can make the appropriate changes. The ability to pause the reading and review certain sections should greatly help them.
The first objective will be accomplished through the comments feature of Microsoft Word. The students will share their story with a peer who will review it and provide the specific written responses that the objective calls for. The students will then revise their writings in response to their peer’s comments, again, just as the objective calls for.
TP-Technology & Pedagogy
My main pedagogical goal in teaching writing is to develop writers who can independently monitor their writings, adjust what needs to be changed, and produce a finished polished product that conveys their meaning. My planned lesson will help to accomplish this goal. The use of vozme.com will allow the students to self-monitor their writing and by listening to what they wrote, change their writings. Pedagogically it is very important to make learning meaningful. If a student cannot answer the question ‘When am I going to use this?’, they have not reason to learn the information. When instructing students using technology it is essential to remember this. If I am going to introduce my students to a technology or program, such as vozme or the comments feature of Microsoft Word, I need to show them how they can practically apply the new information. If I am able to do so, the new knowledge becomes essential, and therefore will stick around.
By using the technology to edit, students will be able to engage with writing in a much more enjoyable way. Gone will be the days where editing a story means writing and rewriting it over again by hand. Students will longer be afraid to mark up a document, as all markup can easily be addressed and then removed. I feel the lowered burden of work itself will help my students engage in editing in a deeper way.
PC- Pedagogy & Content
The content of editing is not something that easily lends itself to high quality pedagogy. Editing can be a tedious and time-consuming process, one with very low student interest and low engagement levels. I like to teach in a more constructivist manner, letting the students build their own knowledge through personal experiences. I have tried to accomplish this with editing, but constructivism relies on students’ innate curiosity about things, and I have not yet met a student with an innate curiosity about editing. Some students desire to be great writers, but they want to focus more on ideas, not necessarily the mechanics. The personal pedagogical struggle in this content area was the driving force behind my desire to attack this problem using technology. I am hoping that the introduction of technology to the process will spark the students’ curiosity and drive them to work hard to improve their writing.
Steve,
ReplyDeleteGreat idea on using vozMe.com to help your students pick out the places where their writing does not make sense. I run into the same problem with my fifth graders and although I have them go out in the hallway and read their writing piece aloud to themselves, many still finish in less than five minutes without editing anything. Do the students type out their stories on vozMe first or are you going to type them out? The only problem I see with this is how time consuming it will be for the children to type out their stories. We both know the fifth grade curriculum is very intense. Good luck with this. I look forward to finding out how this works with your kids and if it is something I could possibly implement in my classroom. This could be a possible differentiation tool to use with my low writers.
I think it is a great idea to use vozMe.com to have your students hear their writing aloud. I can also see how it could become very time consuming to have the students type out their writing. I can also see a benefit to that because when students have to type out their writing it is another time they are reading through it and can find mistakes or changes that need to be made. By setting up specific guidelines for students to make comments on another student's writing using technology is a great way to make it more exciting and engaging. I look forward to hearing how this works for your class!
ReplyDeleteYour passion for maximizing student learning is evident in your blog post. I hope your approach finds success, and that it compliments your constructivist approach in the classroom. Editing may not be initially engaging, but it is essential. The use of technology in the way that you have described could make a huge difference in overall engagement and enthusiasm about editing. I hope the implementation goes well!
ReplyDeleteI love this idea of editing on the computer! It is so daunting to make corrections only to think that you have to rewrite the draft and someone else will tear it apart again. This way they can accept or deny changes that are made and keep their drafts in tact. The only concerns I have are minor. Are you then teaching them the grammar or writing process in addition to actually editing the pieces? My students think that they can change just the problems I point out and that it is completely fine. Will you be emphasizing editing for content or just surface level mistakes? I am trying to get my students to dig deeper and really make their writing more detailed, but they are struggling. Maybe you could use a rubric through google forms for them to asses their own ability to edit and hold them accountable, not just for the end result, but for the entire process. Vozme will be great for the students to hear their story and edit, but how will they keep up with the reader making corrections. They may need to listen to the story a few times before really getting their corrections down. It may help for someone else to read their story because as we read we put in words that are not there if we know what we are trying to say. By having another student read and record their piece it will be more evident if it is not read smoothly. Just a few suggestions! I think this is excellent and I'd love to use this with my 4th graders!
ReplyDelete