One technology listed that I truly enjoy using and find very valuable are WebQuests. I love how well constructed WebQuests engage the students in new learning and allow them the freedom to explore the concepts in their own way. I am a firm believer in constructivism. I feel that until a learner builds a new piece of knowledge into something that fits their schema, they really do not learn. WebQuests provide a great opportunity to do this, as they naturally follow a students’ exploration of a concept.
Two of the technologies that I feel would not be effective with my students are Wikis and Interactive Discussions between Students. I feel that these technologies can be incredibly effective, in fact, during the course of this Master’s Program I have learned much through utilization of both. However, my students’ maturity level as 5th graders makes them very challenging. Through much personal experience with the age level, I have found that students have a very difficult time of publicly expressing an opinion contrary to another classmate’s. I feel that using both Wikis and Interactive Discussions require a certain amount of civil discourse amongst the participants, and my 5th graders are not quite at that stage yet. We have, as a class, participated in a video conference given by an author of a novel that we read, and the students really enjoyed it. It was very beneficial, but it was a one-sided conversation. It was not however, a discussion like these two technologies are. Understanding this, I would like my students to experience those technologies due to their usefulness, but it requires more structure than an open forum.
I feel that online learning is most useful in more wide-open learning experiences. Concepts such as ‘Which Native American tribe was hurt the most by contact with the Europeans?’ would be an excellent topic for students to explore online. One of the greatest features of online learning is the myriad of knowledge that exists in easily accessible places. A question like the one previously mentioned would allow students to approach a conclusion from multiple angles and use multiple resources. I feel that more closed ended questions such as ‘What is the formula for the area of a trapezoid?’ do not fully utilize everything that online learning has to offer. All the students must do in that situation is a simple search, find, and record, no higher level thinking occurs. Open-ended questions require a student to evaluate information for validity and synthesize new information with existing knowledge, both of which are higher level thinking activities.
Overall, I feel that online learning allows students to interact with information in a more organic manner. Instead of the traditional model where a teacher forces as much information at a student as possible followed by a test and the subsequent purging of that information, online learning allows students to naturally engage in learning. The interactivity of technology allows students a meaningful learning experience where they get to decide how they will learn the required material.
Steve, I appreciate your comment about the age-appropriateness of wikis and interactive discussions. Can 5th grade students utilize these technologies? Yes. But, given their age, the tools may not be as useful and meaningful.
ReplyDeleteI like how you called online learning as more, "organic." Looking at the experience in that way paints a good picture for me.
Thanks for sharing!